OTEPs Over-Delivery in 2009

April 21st 2010 at 11:00am, By Dave Guerin

This post follows up from posts on wananga and university over-delivery in 2009 over the last two days – the university post explains the context. The short version is that providers are supposed to be in the 97-103% range, if 100% is their funding allocation

So, what’s an OTEP? Well, it’s an Other Tertiary Education Provider, which really means that it’s an organisation that doesn’t easily fit in the box, so  that the government either gives it a different or a better funding deal than those that fit in neat boxes. Here’s some context on each:

  • the NZ School of Drama is a private training establishment that gets more  funding for drama courses than any public institution, but that’s because it has been designated as a national centre for drama training since it was founded;
  • Taratahi Agricultural Training Centre is a PTE but gets funded like a public institution, but it is actually established by an Act (it was set up to train WW1 returned servicemen) and was originally funded by the Ministry of Agriculture;
  • The Playcentre Federation, Childcare Assn and Te Kohanga Reo Trust had historic funding allocations for training through the MOE for their early childhood education work;
  • Literacy Aotearoa also had historic funding through the MOE; and
  • The Institute of Professional Legal Studies is, curiously, the only one that is completely private sector but also had a historic funding arrangement (given there are lawyers involved, I might write up a separate post about that one day).

So, how did they do in 2009? IPLS performed very poorly and will probably have to give a lot of money back, but 2 OTEPs were just over 100%. Four OTEPs were well over the 103% limit, all in the high-demand early childhood education and literacy areas. It will be interesting to see if anything happens there. I say that because OTEPs and PTEs often have quite high over-delivery and the management of it has not been such a major concern for the TEC. Up until 2008 all places at tertiary education institutions were funded, but PTEs had many unfunded places – I imagine some OTEPs may have been in the same position, or have been allowed to expand unfunded enrolments in the last two years.

OTEPs Over/Under Delivery
Institute of Professional Legal Studies 69.5%
Taratahi Agricultural Training Centre 101.1%
Te Kura Toi Whakaari o Aotearoa: NZ Drama School 102.2%
Te Tai Puna Ora O Aotearoa/ NZ Childcare Assn 106.5%
Te Kohanga Reo National Trust Board 116.7%
NZ Playcentre Federation 119.8%
Literacy Aotearoa 134.8%
Total 107.4%

Tomorrow we’ll cover ITPs. Over/Under Delivery percentage is derived from data supplied by the TEC.

3 Responses to OTEPs Over-Delivery in 2009

Avatar

Stephen Carr

April 22nd, 2010 at 10:26 am

Hi
I should just point out that Taratahi is not a PTE, but is certainly true that our unique status and method of establishment way back in 1919 does give us a “different” look to many training providers. Ultimately our Board reports to the Minister of Agriculture, so this together with our Act of Parliament makes us very different to a PTE!

Avatar

Dave Guerin

April 22nd, 2010 at 1:19 pm

Taratahi is designated by NZQA as a PTE (http://nzqa.govt.nz/providers/results.do?regionCode=0&typeCode=PTE&nameQuery=taratahi), but its formal legal status is as a Crown entity (from memory). It is also classed as an OTEP by the TEC. So it’s fair to say that “PTE” is not the best term to describe Taratahi, but it is one of the terms that can be used.

My colleague David Choat and I were discussing this issue by email yesterday in relation to an MOE Youth Training report that broke PTEs down into many categories. While many organisations are classed as PTEs, they may also have other conflicting designations, such as Taratahi’s OTEP status or a city/district council.

Disclosure: I have done several projects for Taratahi over the years, including one last year.

Avatar

Stephen Carr

April 22nd, 2010 at 4:32 pm

It is true that some organisations class us as a PTE. NZQA do it because OTEP does not appear on their pulldown pick list! :-)

Comment Form

sidebared.jpg
  • Richard Hamilton-Williams: Tinkering with funding on the basis of the age of students doesn’t have a very successful track re [...]
  • dean: I loved that you started to question my own motives. BTW. [...]
  • dean: Well, err, um i was actually trying to point out how potentially futile ascribing motive to somethin [...]
  • Dave Guerin: Dean, an organisation can argue as it wishes. Given the collection of stories and releases today, NZ [...]
  • dean: Sigh, really ... You question (am I right in saying negatively?) an organisation's motives on som [...]