News 22 Feb – Smart Drugs, Cadets and Academics with Guns

February 22nd 2010 at 8:31am, By Dave Guerin

There were lots of news stories on Saturday, so check them out if you haven’t already. Comments on the stories below or any issues of the day are welcome.

  1. Labour is continuing to argue with National over student loans. Grant Robertson’s post title on Red Alert over the weekend was that Steven Joyce was perpetuating myths on student loans. The Labour MP picks up on Joyce’s statement that students don’t face an incentive to pay students loans back, but Joyce’s statement is in the right direction, if incomplete – students face no incentive to pay back their student loan earlybecause the loan’s real value will decline over time with no interest being incurred.  My suggestion would be that we stop calling this policy a loan scheme – it’s mainly an allowance scheme now – or that we put real interest back in the equation, rather than have MPs argue over semantics. Maryan Street of Labour takes a different spin on the issue, suggesting that National is seeking to close down access through student loans scheme changes. Both Labour MPs are trying to chip away at National in the absence of specific issues, but I’m sure they will be more effective once National says something serious on the issue.
  2. In an era when duplication in qualifications is a problem, I was curious when I saw a story about qualifications for cadet forces. So I checked out the National Certificate in Cadet Forces (Foundation Skills) Level 2 and found that it has 50 credits, and only 21/34 compulsory credits are specific to the ITO (Learning State) and domain (Cadet Forces). Within the compulsory Cadet Forces domain unit standards, some of them cover skills that must be covered by other unit standards (leadership, firearms use, risk management, radio telephone use). Overall, I was left wondering whether we needed a qualification in Cadet Forces when other qualifications might do the trick.
  3. Orientation: Otago police tell students to be good.
  4. In the UK, researchers are suggesting that students might be drug-tested at examinations in the future. This is not to make sure that students are “appropriate role models”, like in sport, but because drugs like Ritalin can greatly improve alertness and attention. HT Dean Carroll
  5. The European Commission has released a new paper titled Assessing Europe’s University-Based Research - Expert Group on Assessment of University-Based Research. I haven’t read all (or much) of its 151 pages, but I may do and you should consider doing so too if research assessment is your thing.
  6. Some of you may have been following the story of the professor who shot her colleagues in Alabama, apparently as a result of not getting tenure. The Chronicle of Higher Education had an in-depth story on the issue over the weekend that is worth a read – much better insight than a wire story.

4 Responses to News 22 Feb – Smart Drugs, Cadets and Academics with Guns

Avatar

Dean Carroll

February 22nd, 2010 at 9:37 am

For those of you interested in a more in-depth article on performance enhancing drugs for academic activities the New Yorker did an excellent piece last April on what is now becoming quite an issue for the American system.

http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/04/27/090427fa_fact_talbot

Avatar

Darel

February 22nd, 2010 at 11:49 am

It wasn’t that long ago (1999) that five and a half thousand UC students presented a petition to parliament asking that student loans attract CPI only. I believe petitioners believed that retaining the real value of the debt was fair, charging interest while studying was not.

Many of the posts on Red Alert are a variation on the theme that their qualification didn’t get then a well-paid job. That supports Joyce’s thinking, which from memory Labour Ministers also expressed, that more, not all, qualifications ought to be directly linked to the labour market.

Avatar

Dave Guerin

February 22nd, 2010 at 1:55 pm

I can’t see National making any major changes this term – probably just some changes for access by “poor performers” and the universities will come out in support of that. Any interest would have to be a second term issue because National doesn’t want to buy a fight on going back on a big election promise. But real interest is pretty likely to be an election policy next time around.

And if you don’t get a well-paying job, your debt will get smaller in real terms over the years. I had a poorly paying job out of university and my debt got bigger in real terms!

Avatar

Darel

February 22nd, 2010 at 3:57 pm

I do hope Dean’s work comes off such that prospective students have good information about what they are signing up for and likely returns when enroling. This looks like an interesting exercise: http://exmss.org/rate-it/

Comment Form

Education Directions

Education Directions Ltd (ED) improves tertiary education's impact on lifting workforce productivity. We do that by linking the key players in tertiary education through information, strategy and policy.

ED Blog covers New Zealand tertiary education news and views. Comments and guest posts are welcome. If you have a news tip, please contact us.

ED Insider

ED Insider provides strategic information and analysis for tertiary education professionals - it's the big brother of ED Blog. Check it out now!

  • Dean Carroll: I agree Darel; another positive externality. I also think that Dave overstates the barriers. Surely [...]
  • Darel: I agree Dean. I wonder if one of the side benefits is to get people constructively focused on t [...]
  • Dean Carroll: I too think that this is an excellent idea as it (a) focuses on the effective and efficiency of the [...]
  • Big News: My follow up to the Massey enrolment cuts is <a href="http://big-news.blogspot.com/2010/07/b [...]
  • Sheldon Nesdale: All that news in just one day Dave? [...]