ITP Council Musical Chairs 3 – CEO, Student & Staff Roles

February 4th 2010 at 4:41pm, By Dave Guerin

Musical ChairsThis post reviews whether CEOs, students and staff should have designated roles on Councils – its the third in a series on ITP Council arrangements – and my view is “no, but”.

I’ve been a student rep on a Council (Victoria Uni, 1993) and I did a good job, as have most of my predecessors and successors. Vic students have had two reps on Council for 40 years, even though the law only requires one, but that second position was created after the student reps had built a reputation and an argument for it over years. The two roles have been maintained through generally solid performance by each year’s reps, based on the work of many other student reps and students’ assn staff. That’s the model that I prefer – appointment based on merit.

Staff and student reps can add something very useful to any tertiary education institution Council, but not just because they are a student or staff member. To be effective, the individual needs to have strong skills and they need an effective support network to boost their reach and credibility (unions and students’ associations could, but do not always, provide that). Support networks are even more important for student reps, as they often have one year terms, and institutional memory through staff and long-term student reps is crucial. Unfortunately, many ITP students’ assns do not have strong continuity. As ITPs design their new Council arrangements, I suspect that staff and student reps will fall by the wayside due to rationing of places, prior performance, prejudice on the part of other Council members and a poor case being put forward by the current reps (and their supporters). If the same debate around Council composition happened in universities, students and staff would most likely retain their places because they make a stronger contribution and the organisational culture supports them to do so – ITPs are different. Some good comments were made on this issue in an earlier post here.

CEOs should certainly have the skills, experience and support to contribute effectively to the Council – if they can’t, they are probably being performance managed out anyway! My preference, though, would be to keep them off the Council. It simply creates a clearer distinction between employer and employee, which is important for oversight of the CEO.  That said, this should be a choice for the Council to make, and they should be held accountable for it. I suspect that 18-20 of the 20 CEOs will stay on the Coucils after May 1.

UCOL made its decisions last week and has put its Council papers up online - the papers provide useful ideas (although I’m not sure that Mai Chen’s paper on whether a CEO should be on the Council should have been addressed to the current CEO – surely the Chairperson should have been briefing Mai, but the underlying process may have involved the Chair, of course). UCOL have appointed their CEO, Chair, Deputy Chair and Finance Ctte Chair as the four ongoing members – not staff or students to my knowledge.

In terms of making a case, it is curious to note that the UCOL Council did not consider any written input from staff or student groups at their meeting last week on this issue – surely this was a great chance to put forward a positive case? The TEU has complained today about the result, but what are they and NZUSA proactively doing for the other ITPs?

Comment Form

Education Directions

Education Directions Ltd (ED) improves tertiary education's impact on lifting workforce productivity. We do that by linking the key players in tertiary education through information, strategy and policy.

ED Blog is for people working in and around NZ tertiary education who care about policy, strategy and results. Comments and guest posts are welcome. If you have a news tip, please contact us.

ED Insider

ED Insider, our newest service, provides strategic information and analysis for tertiary education professionals - find out more.

Facebook

@eddirections Twitter Feed – Sign Up

Meltwater Newsfeed : ED Blog Newsfeed

  • Kiwis tapping the iPhone's potential March 18, 2010
    It's a well-worn adage, especially within the software development industry, but necessity really is the mother of invention for some of New Zealand's most successful iPhone application developers. […]
  • Dozen Witt staff face the axe | Stuff.co.nz March 18, 2010
    Up to 12 full-time staff will be axed as Witt tries to make up for a $2.25 million funding cut expected next year. Consultation has already been completed with the affected employees, who work across a number of areas and it could be finalised this week. […]
  • Lincoln, Teleford study merger proposal March 18, 2010
    Lincoln University and Telford Rural Polytechnic are exploring a possible merger of their two institutions in the coming year. The merger talks have been prompted by the tertiary shake-up that looks set to "squeeze" the South Otago rural training institution. […]
  • Study Looks At Exceptional Māori Students March 18, 2010
    Outstanding Māori secondary school students are the focus of new research into what factors influence their success. University of Auckland Faculty of Education lecturer Melinda Webber is one of four researchers, all of Te Arawa descent, who have gone back into their Rotorua community to profile Māori... […]
  • Southern School of Swing Set to Succeed March 18, 2010
    The University of Canterbury’s proposal for a new music school is looking to go ahead, while Wellington plans of a similar nature lay in the pipeline. […]
  • Designer praises iD Fashion to the heavens March 18, 2010
    While the Dunedin fashion scene recovers from a week packed with 16 events, including two sold-out shows, organisers of iD Dunedin Fashion Week are already thinking of next year. […]
  • Fees may put tertiary study 'out of reach' March 18, 2010
    The cost of tertiary study is rising and Government changes could make it dearer still. Critics are worried spiralling costs will take higher study out of reach for some people. […]
  • Editorial: Tapping potential March 18, 2010
    OPINION: The selection of two irrigation schemes among the four winners of a competition to find projects with a long-term potential capacity to make a significant contribution to the Canterbury economy demonstrates the significance of the appropriate use of its water resource to the region. […]
  • Failing students may get two-year reprieve before losing loans March 18, 2010
    Tertiary students failing more than half their papers may be given a two-year time limit to prove they are worthy of keeping student loans. Tertiary Minister Steven Joyce has floated plans to make obtaining student loans subject to a student's success, but details of how it would work are yet to be finalised. […]
  • Exam time for the tertiary education sector March 18, 2010
    Welcome to Tertiary Education Challenge, here is your starter for 10: How many tourism qualifications does a country of four million people need? Let's put it another way. […]
  • Aoraki restructure too fast – union March 18, 2010
    The Tertiary Education Union says Aoraki Polytechnic's restructure is "risky". Six top-level jobs will be axed and new positions created under a new school structure, which Aoraki chief executive Kay Nelson said would help meet the Government's latest demands for the tertiary sector. […]
Site Meter