ITP Council Musical Chairs 1 – UCOL

February 2nd 2010 at 12:30pm, By Dave Guerin

Musical ChairsIt’s musical chairs time in ITPs as an average of 14 Council members at each ITP need to fit into the new 8-person Councils from May 1. This is the first post in a series on the new arrangements – in the next post, I’ll do a deeper analysis of the issues, but today I’ll focus on UCOL.

Just before Xmas, the Government passed the Education (Polytechnic ) Amendment Act 2009, which will result in smaller Councils. Compulsory appointment types have also been removed, such as the CEO and student, staff, employer and union representatives. In short, there will now be eight Council members, four appointed by the Minister and four appointed by the Council. The current Councils are deciding appointment methods now.

UCOL decided last week that they would only specify roles for the CEO and an iwi representative, while the other two roles will apparently be chosen by the Council, on skills and background.

The council also agreed on a new statute which outlined the skills nominees required. UCOL chief executive Paul McElroy said the statute aimed to create a balance of representatives. Applicants’ gender, ethnicity, and location will be considered, as well as skills such as tertiary knowledge, governance experience, business background and leadership qualities.

Students and staff (other than the CEO) will probably miss out under this approach, although UCOL might set up a committee to get student input.

ITP Council Musical Chairs Series

  1. UCOL
  2. The Backstory
  3. CEO, Student and Staff Roles
  4. Otago
  5. External Roles
  6. Ministerial Appointees
  7. Minister’s Decisions
  8. The Final Shape of ITP Councils?

4 Responses to ITP Council Musical Chairs 1 – UCOL

Avatar

Darel Hall

February 2nd, 2010 at 1:38 pm

I do think that having student representatives on Councils is good. I don’t believe a committee reporting to Council cuts it.

Some people point to problems with the legitimacy of student representatives, eg how can they represent all students’ views? The same, of course, applies to business, union, staff and all reps. It is a facet, not a problem of representation.

I thought the TEC decision to have a non-voting Learner Rep at their board meetings was a halfway measure that looks messy but seemed to work because in many of these situations it’s the voice that matters not the voting (so why not give them the vote . . ).

There was an opinion piece in the Ed Review that argued that student representation on councils was bad, but I actually think he (can’t remember his name) was really on about VSM/ CSM. Are there other views about the value of student representation on councils?

Avatar

Paul Williams

February 2nd, 2010 at 4:00 pm

I’d have to say that my observations of various councils leaves me with mixed views as to their effectiveness. I thought rorting of public funding at CPIT was as much a CEO and a governance failure, similarly I wondered where the council was with Otago Poly discovered major flaws in their financial reporting. Then again I’ve been a member of a university council that seemed clear about it’s role and keen to provide strategic leadership (Waikato in the mid ’90s). I’d be a hypocrite if I didn’t worry about how student voices are affected by these reforms.

Leaving aside the issue of the number of members, what seems most important to me is that the boad knows its role, is capable and resourced to do it and is accountable both to Ministers and to the regional community. I wonder if any Ministerial appointees recall being contacted by the Minister or the Ministry and asked to account for their contibutions? Perhaps this is what Alan Sarginson did way back when?

Avatar

David Choat

February 2nd, 2010 at 5:06 pm

Actually, TAMU’s advice at that stage (and I assume still TEC’s today) is that these people are Ministerial appointees rather than representatives, and it would be inappropriate (and a breach of Section 160?) for the Minister or his/her representatives to do any such thing.

But they did draft for the Minister a set of Ministerial Expectations that applied to all Council members in terms of their duties under the Act.

Avatar

Paul Williams

February 2nd, 2010 at 8:59 pm

I’ll not quibble on the law since presumably they had Crown Law’s advice but the insensibility of that must surely be apparent? I’ll simply reiterate my view that the performance of council/governing bodies seemed oddly inconsistent and I’d've thought that an important issue for governments (note the plural).

Comment Form

Education Directions

Education Directions Ltd (ED) improves tertiary education's impact on lifting workforce productivity. We do that by linking the key players in tertiary education through information, strategy and policy.

ED Blog is for people working in and around NZ tertiary education who care about policy, strategy and results. Comments and guest posts are welcome. If you have a news tip, please contact us.

ED Insider

ED Insider, our newest service, provides strategic information and analysis for tertiary education professionals - find out more.

  • DesiBackToDesh: Does that mean that stupidity will breed itself out of existence? [...]
  • NMG: ...and yet the world hasn't ended. [...]
  • David Choat: Thanks very much for that, Matt - very informative! And I definitely take your last point about p [...]
  • Matt Nolan: "Are they really completely “apples and oranges”, Matt? Or is the difference between the labour- [...]
  • David Choat: Okay, finally got around to reading the Hot Off the Press. Are they really completely "apples and [...]

Facebook

@eddirections Twitter Feed – Sign Up

Meltwater Newsfeed : ED Blog Newsfeed

  • Kiwis tapping the iPhone's potential March 18, 2010
    It's a well-worn adage, especially within the software development industry, but necessity really is the mother of invention for some of New Zealand's most successful iPhone application developers. […]
  • Dozen Witt staff face the axe | Stuff.co.nz March 18, 2010
    Up to 12 full-time staff will be axed as Witt tries to make up for a $2.25 million funding cut expected next year. Consultation has already been completed with the affected employees, who work across a number of areas and it could be finalised this week. […]
  • Lincoln, Teleford study merger proposal March 18, 2010
    Lincoln University and Telford Rural Polytechnic are exploring a possible merger of their two institutions in the coming year. The merger talks have been prompted by the tertiary shake-up that looks set to "squeeze" the South Otago rural training institution. […]
  • Study Looks At Exceptional Māori Students March 18, 2010
    Outstanding Māori secondary school students are the focus of new research into what factors influence their success. University of Auckland Faculty of Education lecturer Melinda Webber is one of four researchers, all of Te Arawa descent, who have gone back into their Rotorua community to profile Māori... […]
  • Southern School of Swing Set to Succeed March 18, 2010
    The University of Canterbury’s proposal for a new music school is looking to go ahead, while Wellington plans of a similar nature lay in the pipeline. […]
  • Designer praises iD Fashion to the heavens March 18, 2010
    While the Dunedin fashion scene recovers from a week packed with 16 events, including two sold-out shows, organisers of iD Dunedin Fashion Week are already thinking of next year. […]
  • Fees may put tertiary study 'out of reach' March 18, 2010
    The cost of tertiary study is rising and Government changes could make it dearer still. Critics are worried spiralling costs will take higher study out of reach for some people. […]
  • Editorial: Tapping potential March 18, 2010
    OPINION: The selection of two irrigation schemes among the four winners of a competition to find projects with a long-term potential capacity to make a significant contribution to the Canterbury economy demonstrates the significance of the appropriate use of its water resource to the region. […]
  • Failing students may get two-year reprieve before losing loans March 18, 2010
    Tertiary students failing more than half their papers may be given a two-year time limit to prove they are worthy of keeping student loans. Tertiary Minister Steven Joyce has floated plans to make obtaining student loans subject to a student's success, but details of how it would work are yet to be finalised. […]
  • Exam time for the tertiary education sector March 18, 2010
    Welcome to Tertiary Education Challenge, here is your starter for 10: How many tourism qualifications does a country of four million people need? Let's put it another way. […]
  • Aoraki restructure too fast – union March 18, 2010
    The Tertiary Education Union says Aoraki Polytechnic's restructure is "risky". Six top-level jobs will be axed and new positions created under a new school structure, which Aoraki chief executive Kay Nelson said would help meet the Government's latest demands for the tertiary sector. […]
Site Meter

Categories

Archives

Copyright © 2010 - Education Directions Log in